What kind of guy has long fingernails? Is he on Team Jacob and shows it by growing his fingernails long like a werewolf? Hey, I love Teen Wolf as much as the next girl, but I feel like guys with long fingernails aren't party animal high school basketball players; they're more likely to go to Burning Man, make their own lentil soup and have farts that smell like a Calcutta bazaar in August. It's gross!
Well, maybe if he just cut his fingernails down to a reasonable length for an adult male to have I'd consider letting him touch me. Maybe. But, now I know that he's the kind of guy to have long fingernails so don't need a Magic 8 Ball to tell me that the "outlook is not so good" about that.